Who Flung Dung?

Guides For Arses
Economics & Dirt | 5 Min Read

Why Are We Still Importing Dung? A Guide to Sovereign Fertiliser Manufacturing

CB

By The Cynical Bastard

October 4, 2026

Satirical representation of sovereign manufacturing
Artist's Impression of Australian Planning
WARNING

Disclaimer: The following is a satirical oversimplification of complex geopolitical and economic issues. It contains traces of snark, high levels of cynicism, and may cause severe eye-rolling in current or former politicians. It is definitely not financial advice. Or agricultural advice. Please don't eat fertiliser.

Alright, mates. Settle in. Today on Guides For Arses, we’re going to talk about poop. Well, the synthetic equivalent of poop. We’re talking about fertiliser.

You see, Australia is a massive country with a lot of dirt, and we grow a lot of food in that dirt. To make the food grow well, we need fertiliser. You’d think, given we are girt by sea and largely isolated from the rest of the world, we’d want to make our own, right? That’s what fancy people call "sovereign manufacturing capability." It means making your own stuff so you don't panic when the global supply chain has a meltdown (looking at you, Suez Canal ship).

So, why haven't successive governments jumped at the chance to secure this? Why do we still rely heavily on importing the very stuff that makes our food grow? Let's break it down into simple, bite-sized pieces that even a politician could digest (eventually).

1 The "She'll Be Right, Mate" Strategy

For decades, the global supply chain was like a reliable, slightly boring friend. You ordered urea (the nitrogen-rich good stuff), and it arrived. Why bother building expensive factories here when we could just buy it cheaper from somewhere else?

Successive governments basically looked at the spreadsheet, saw that importing was cheaper than building, and said, "She'll be right." They bet the farm (literally) on the idea that global peace and free trade would last forever. It’s the equivalent of never buying an umbrella because it hasn't rained in a week.

2 The Gas Conundrum

Fertiliser manufacturing, particularly nitrogen fertiliser, requires a massive amount of natural gas. Now, you might be thinking, "Hang on, doesn't Australia have shedloads of gas?"

Yes. Yes, we do. We extract so much gas we're practically farting it.

The problem is, we are very, very good at digging things out of the ground and immediately putting them on ships to sell to other countries. We set up these massive export deals years ago. So, even though we have the gas, getting it cheaply for domestic use (like making fertiliser) is harder than convincing a cat to take a bath.

Governments have occasionally mumbled about "gas reservation policies" (keeping some gas for us), but the big gas companies usually cough loudly, point to their shiny export contracts, and the government decides it's all a bit too hard.

3 The Shiny Object Syndrome

Let's be honest, building a fertiliser plant isn't sexy. It doesn't win votes in the same way a new sports stadium or a high-speed rail line (that never gets built) does.

Politicians operate on a three-year cycle. Building a massive, complex chemical manufacturing facility takes time, planning, and a lot of money. The politician who approves the funding might not be around to cut the ribbon. Therefore, it falls into the "Too Hard/Not Shiny Enough" basket.

4 The Fear of Picking Winners

Governments are terrified of "picking winners." If they give a massive subsidy to Company A to build a fertiliser plant, and Company A goes bust, the government looks stupid. It's much safer to just let the "free market" sort it out.

The problem is, the free market in fertiliser is currently dominated by countries that do heavily subsidise their industries. We are trying to play a game of Monopoly where the other players started with hotels on Mayfair and Park Lane, and we’re just hoping to pass Go.


The Bottom Line

So, there you have it. A toxic mix of short-term thinking, a reliance on global peace, a weird relationship with our own natural resources, and a fear of unsexy infrastructure projects has left us relying on imported plant food.

Next time you bite into a fresh, locally grown carrot, just remember: it might be Australian soil, but it was probably helped along by some imported magic dust. Bon appétit!

Link copied to clipboard!